Flu vaccine often less effective than health officials claim, study finds
A new study questions how health officials describe flu vaccine protection. Researchers from the University of Maryland analyzed flu vaccine effectiveness data from 2004 through 2024 and found the median protection was 39.5% against infection—below the 40% to 60% range that public health officials and media typically report.
The researchers looked at whether each year's vaccine matched the flu strains actually circulating. They found that in 11 of the 18 seasons studied, the vaccine did not match the strains people encountered. According to the study's senior author, Dr. Justin Ortiz, the 40% to 60% range may describe some seasons but does not reflect how much protection varies from year to year.
The researchers emphasized that lower-than-advertised effectiveness does not mean people should skip the flu shot. Ortiz said the challenge is communicating the uncertainty about protection while keeping people aware of the vaccine's substantial benefits.
What it means in Raleigh
Behavioral health: Alliance Health (LME/MCO for Wake, Durham, Johnston, Orange, Cumberland, Mecklenburg)
Medicaid plans: NC Medicaid Standard Plans: AmeriHealth Caritas NC, Carolina Complete Health, Healthy Blue, UnitedHealthcare Community Plan, WellCare of NC. Tailored Plans: Alliance Health, Trillium Health Resources, Vaya Partners (Vaya Health + Partners Health Management, merged 2026).
Major insurers: Blue Cross NC, Aetna, Cigna, UnitedHealthcare, Humana
Plan lists change; confirm with your plan or the state agency.
